Friday, October 14, 2011

The President of Contempt

By Bret Stephens

Nixon was tricky. Ford was clumsy. Carter was dour. Reagan was sunny. Bush 41 was prudent. Clinton felt your pain. Bush 43 was stubborn. And Barach Obama is...

Early in America's acquaintance with the man who would become the 44th president, the word that typically sprang from media lips to describe him was "cool."

Cool as a matter of fashion sense - "Who does he think he is, George Clooney?" burbed the blogger Wonkette in April 2008. Cool as a matter of political temperment - "Maybe after eight years of George W. Bush stubborness, on the heels of eight years of Clinton emotiveness, we need to send out for ice" approved USA Today's Ruben Navarrette that October. Cool as a matter of upbringing - Indonesia, apparently, is "Where Barack learned to be cool," according to a family friend quoted in a biography of his mother.

The Obama cool made for a reassuring contrast with his campaign's warm-and-fuzzy appeals to hope, change and being the one we've been waiting for. But as the American writer Minna Antrim observed long ago,"between flattery and admiration there often flows a river of contempt." When it comes to Mr. Obama, boy does it ever.

We caught flashes of the contempt during the campaign. There were those small-town Midwesterners who, as he put it at a San Francisco fund raiser, "cling to guns or religion or antipathy to people who are not like them." There were those racist Republicans who as he put it at a Jacksonville fundraiser would campaign against him by asking, "Did I mention that he was black?" There was the "you're likable enough Hillary," line during a New Hampshire debate. But these were unscripted disgressions and could be written off as such.

Only after Mr. Obama came to office did it start to become clear that contempt would be both a style and method of his governance. Take the "mess we have inherited." line, which became the administrations ring tone for its first two years.

"I have never seen anything like the mess we have inherited," said the late Richard Holbrooke-a man with memories of what Nixon inherited in Vietnam from Johnson -and about Afghanistan in February 2009. "We are cleaning up something that is-quite simply-a mess ," said the president the following month about Guantanamo. "Let's face it, we inherited a mess," said Valiere Jarrett about the economy in March 2010.

For presidential candidates to rail against incumbents from an opposing party is normal, for a president to rail for years against a predecessor of any party is crass-and something to which neither Reagan nor Lincoln, each of them inheritors of much bigger messes, stooped.

Then again, the contempt Mr. Obama felt for the Bush administration was mearly of a piece with the broader ambit of his distain. Example? Here's a quick list: The gratuitous return of the Churchill bust in Britain. The slam of the Boston police officer who arrested Henry Louis Gates. The high profile rebuke of the members of the Supreme Court at his 2010 State of the Union speech. The diplomatic snubs, of Gordan Brown, Benjamin Netanyahu and Nickolas Sarkozy. The verbal assaults on Wall Street "fat cats" who "caused the problem" of "10% unemployment." The never-ending baiting of millionaires and billionaires and jet owners and anyone else who, as Black Entertainment Television's Robert Johnson memorably put it on Sunday, "tried rich and tried poor and like rich better."

Now we come to the last few days, in which Mr. Obama first admonished the Congressional Black Caucus to "stop complainin', stop grumblin', stop cryin'," and later told a Florida TV station that America was losing its competative edge because it "had gotten a little soft." The first comment earned a rebuke from none other than Rep. Maxine Waters, while the second elicited instant comparisons to Jimmy Carter's "malaise" speech. They tell us something about the president's political IQ. They tell us more about his world view.

What is it that Mr. Obama doesn't like about the United States-a country that sent him hurtling like an American Idol contestant from the obscurity of an Illinois Senate seat to the presidency in a mere four years?

I suspect it's the same thing that so many run-of-the-mill liberals dislike: Americans typically believe that happiness is an idividual persuit; we bridle at other people setting limits on what's "enough"; we enjoy wealth and want to keep as much of it as we can; we don't like trading in our own freedom for someone else's idea of virtue, much less a fabricated contempt of the collective good.

When a good history of anti-Americanism is someday written, it will note that it's mainly a story of disenchantment-of the obdurate and sometimes vulgar reality of the country falling short of the lover's ideal. Listening to Mr.Obama, especially now as the country turns against him, one senses in him a similiar disenchantment: America is lovable exactly in proportion to the love it gives him in return.

Hence his increasingly ill-concealed expressions of contempt. Hence the increasingly widespread couter-contempt.

The Dignified Statesman

By Brian McGrory

KENNEBUNKPORT, Maine - Patten's Berry Farm is the kind of place a Hollywood producer would want to invent if it didn't already exist, with Mrs. Patten selling corn, apples, and pumpkins on the side of a country road in this impossibly pretty town.

I happened to be chatting about the Patriots with the nice woman at the cash register on a quiet Sunday morning when a gleeming black sedan pulled into the parking lot. The front doors opened and men emerged. The back passenger door opened. When I looked up again, George H. W. Bush, the former president, sat in a wheelchair between his car and mine.

This is not unusual, seeing George Bush, the original George Bush, in this town. He was, until a couple of years ago, a fairly regular golfer at Cape Arundel, a fixture on his power boat, an occasional diner at the Hurricance in Dock Square. He orders lobster rolls at the Clam Shack and roams the aisles of the Bradbury Bros. Market. There is little in this world as authentic as George Bush's love of Kennebunkport, Maine.

As we returned to the car, the former president continued to sit, smiling at something I couldn't see. And then I did - our golden retrievers, two of them, their heads poking through the back window pleading for his attention.

"Beautiful dogs," he said. He asked their names - Baker and Walter - then smiled at the answer. I brought up Ranger, the lessor known of his two springer spaniels from his White House days, a dog he loved that died much to young. He said he has a couple of smaller dogs these days.

I didn't tell him I wrote for a newspaper, not that he would have cared, or that I covered his successor, Bill Clinton, or that I once spent the better part of a day with his son when he was governor of Texas. It wasn't worth clouding a moment this clear.

The president extended his arm to shake hands, with me and Pam, who led me on this produce run. I told him he looked good, because he did, sharp and oddly boyish, even at 87 years old in the confines of a wheelchair.

"Spiritual," he replied, whimsically. "I hope I look spiritual. I'm just coming from church."

When we were done, the former president continued on his quiet errand. I should have felt invigorated by this uniquetly American encounter. What I really felt though, was a deep sense of loss.

Five minutes with George H. W. Bush, and the problems of the present are made more vivid by the virtues of the not-so-distant-past. Say what you will, but the unimpeachable fact is that he knew how to govern. His compromise on a tax hike (which cost him his presidency), combined with the spending caps and cuts he put in place, paved the way for the roaring prosperity of the 1990's and the federal surpluses that accompanied it.

He reached across the aisle to pass the Clean Air Act of 1990 and the Americans with Disabilities Act, two landmark accomplishments that have a profound impact on every day life. The war to oust Saddam Hussein's army from Kuwait had a clear mission and a defined end.

That Washington doesn't exist any more. There are no leaders risking their careers in the name of the common good. There are precious few officials seeking compromise rather than cheap political points. There are no bridges, just roadblocks, no reasonable debates, just frantic threats. The extremes, especially on the right, have overwhelmed the middle, and the result is an economy in a government-prolonged rut.

This wasn't exactly a revelation on the side of a country road in Maine, but a moment of clarity. George H. W. Bush's presidency, maybe even Washington as a whole, was quided by decency and dignity.

You don't outgrow these virtues, you simply abandon them. And to spend even a few fleeting minutes with what we had only makes it more regrettable about what we've become.

Monday, September 19, 2011

Mass. GOP Chairwoman announces Resignation

By Glen Johnson, Boston Globe

Jennifer Nassour, chairwoman of the Massachusetts Republican Party, is stepping down as she prepares to have a third child. In an e-mail today to members of the Republican State Committee, the local GOP's top echelon, Nassour wrote, "We are thrilled beyond words and our daughters are incredibly excited. We are also mindful of the additional reponsibility in our already busy lives." She announced that she will resign effective October 28th. The mother of two daughters aged eight and five is slated to have her third child in February.

Nassour, an attorney living in Charlestown, campaigned to be chairman in late 2008 and took over in 2009, navigating a split between the liberal and conservative factions within the State Party.

While chairman, she presided over a resurgence in party metabolism and success, culminating with Scott Brown's upset win in the January 2010 special election to replace the late Senator Edward M. Kennedy and a doubling of the House Republican membership in last fall's state elections.

"I wanted to run, originally, because the party really needed a facelift and some new energy, and I think I succeeded," Nassour told the Globe in an interview. "We have no debt, a good reputation, and I've always tried to greet everyone with an open door, whether they are candidates, the press, or members of the party." she added.

The resignation comes as the state GOP gears up for Brown's re-election. At least six Democrats, including Harvard Law School professor Elizabeth Warren, have announced campaigns for next year's Democratic US Senate nomination.

"The 2012 election year is going to require the party to have a chairman who is focused on the job and able to commit long hours of fund-raising and campaigning." Nassour wrote in her e-mail to the members of the State Committee. "However, family must come first. It is my preference to focus on my family and give someone else the opportunity to lead our party through the upcoming election year. By making a change of leadership in 2011, we give a new chairman the time to get up to speed and lead us to victory in 2012."

Among those first mentioned as possible successors is Mary Connaughton, who narrowly lost an election to serve as state auditor in 2010.

Friday, August 26, 2011

FCC Formally Erases Fairness Doctrine

The Fairness Doctrine, which the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) implemented in 1949 to require broadcasters to present both sides of controversial issues, became less relevent as cable TV exploded in the 1980s. So the FCC dropped the rule in 1987, but it never implemented it - that is, until August 22nd of this year.

The agency formally dumped more than 80 media industry regulations. Other rules the FCC tossed include the "broadcast flag" digital copy protection rule that courts overturned and those pertaining to the cable programming service tier rate.

Monday's action constituted part of the commission's response to an executive order from President Barack Obama implementing a "government-wide review of regulations already on the books" to strike unnecessary rules.

Its ugly, its messy... its democracy

By Charles Krauthammer

Of all the endlessly repeated conventional wisdom in today's Washington, the most lazy, stupid and ubiquitous is that our politics is broken. On the contrary. Our political system is working well (I make no such claims for our economy), indeed, precisely as designed - profound changes in popular will translated into law that alters political direction.

The process has been messy, loud, disputious and often rancorous. So what? In the end, the system works. Exhibit A is Wisconsin. Exhibit B is Washington itself.

The story begins in 2008. The country, having lost confidence in Republican governance, gives the Democrats full controlofWashington. The new president, deciding not to waste a crisis, attempts a major change in the nation's ideological trajectory. Hence his two signature pieces of legislation: a near-$1 trillion stimulus, the largest spending bill in galactic history; and a health-care reform that places one-sixth of the economy under federal control.

In a country where conservatives outnumber liberals 2-1, this causes a reaction. In the 2010 misterms, Democrats suffer a massive repudiation at every level. In Washington, Democrats suffer the greatest loss of House seats since 1948. In the states, they lose more than 700 state legislative seats - the largest reversal ever - resulting in the loss of 20 state chambers.

The tea-party-propelled, debt conscious Republicans then move to confront their states' unsustainable pension and health-care obligations - most boldly in Wisconsin, where the new governor proposes a radical reorientation of the power balance between public-sector unions and elected government.

In Madison, the result is general mayhem - the drum-banging protestors, frenzied unions, statehouse occupations, opposition legislators fleeing the state to prevent a quorum. A veritable feast of creative democratic resistance.

In the end, they fail. The legislation passes.

Then, further resistance. First, Democrats turn an otherwise sleepy state Supreme Court election into a referendum on the union legislation, the Democrats' candidate being widely expected to overturn the law. The unions/Democrats lose again.

And then last Tuesday, recall elections for six Republican state senators, three being needed to return the Senate to Democratic control and restore balance to the universe. Yet despite millions of union dollars, the Republicans hold the Senate. The unions/Democrats lose again.

The people spoke; the process worked. Yes, it was raucous and divisive, but change this fundamental should not be enacted quietly. This is not midnight basketball or school uniforms. This is the future of government-worker power and the solvency of the states. It deserves big, serious, animated public debate.

Precisely of the kind Washington (exhibit B) just witnessed over its debt problem.You know: the debt-ceiling debate universally denounced as dysfunctional, if not disgraceful, hostage taking, terrorism, gun-to-the-head blackmail.

Spare me the hysteria. What happened was that the 2010 electorate, as represented in Congress, forced Washington to finally confront the national debt. It was a triumph of demorcatic politics - a powerful shift in popular will finding concrete political expression.

But only partial expression. Debt hawks are upset that the final compromise doesn't do much. But it shoudn't do much. They won only one election. They were entrusted, as of yet, with only one-half of one branch of government.

But they did begin to turn the aircraft carrier around. The process did bequeath a congressional supercommittee with extraordinary powers to reduce debt. And if that fails, the question - how much government, how much debt -will go to the nation in November 2012. Which is also how it should be.

The conventional complaint is that the process was ugly. Big Deal. You want beauty? Go to a museum. Democratic politics was never meant to be an exercise in aesthetics.

Not just ugly, moan the critics, but oh so slow. True again. It took months. And will take more. The supercommittee doesn't report until Thanksgiving. The next election is more than a year away. But the American system was designed to make a full turn of the carrier difficult and deliberate.

Moreover, without this long ugly process, the debt issue wouldn't even be on the table. We'd still be whistling our way to Greece. Instead, a nation staring at insolvency is finally stirring itself to action, and not without spirited opposition. Great issues are being decided as constitutionally designed. The process is working.

Notice how the loudest complaints about "broken politics" come from those who lost the debate. It's understandable for sore losers to rage against the machine. But there's no need for the rest of us to parrot their petulance.

Wednesday, August 24, 2011

What has America become?

Dear Editor,

Has America become the land of the special interest and home of the double standard?

Lets see: If we lie to Congress, it's a felony and if Congress lies to us its just politics; If we dislike a black person, we're racist and if a black person dislikes whites, it's their 1st Amendment rights; the government spends millions to rehabilitate criminals and they do almost nothing for the victims; In public schools you can teach that homosexuality is OK, but you better not use the work God in the process; you can kill an unborn child, but it is wrong to execute a mass murderer; we don't burn books in America, we now rewrite them; we got rid of the communist and socialist threat by renaming them progressives; we are unable to close our border with Mexico, but we have no problem protecting the 38th parallel in Korea; If you protest against President Obama's policies you're a terrorist, but if you burned an American flag or George Bush in effigy it was your 1st American right.

You can have pornogaphy on TV or the internet, but you better not put up a nativity scene in a public park during Christmas; we have eliminated all criminals in America, they are now called sick people; we can use human fetus for medical research, but it's wrong to use an animal.

We take money from those who work hard for it and give it to those who don't want to work; we all support the Constitution, but only when it supports our political idealogy; we still have freedom of speech, but only if we are politically correct; parenting has been replaced with Ritalin and video games; the land of opportunity is now the land of hand outs; the similarity between Hurricane Katrina and the gulf spill is that neither president did anything to help.

And how do we handle a major crisis today? The government appoints a committee to determine who's at fault, then threatens them, passes a law, raises our taxes; tells us the problem is solved so they can get back to their reelection campaign.

What has happened to the land of the free and home of the brave?

-Ken Huber
Tawas City

Tawas City, MI, is located about halfway up on the shoreline of Lake Huron. The Tawas City Newspaper Editorial... short and to the point...

Friday, August 5, 2011

Sen. Brown to Gov. Patrick - can gas tax plan

Hiking the state's gas tax now could flatten the tourism industry and blow out budgets for working class families who are already struggling to make ends meet, U.S. Sen. Scott Brown said today in a letter to the governor. "I believe the answer at the state level has to be the same as the federal response: cut spending, don't raise taxes."